I meet my “vexatious” accuser face to face !

16 11 13 - improvement - prove it

16th November 2013

I thought I’d turn up to yesterday’s 1:30 pm “Improvement” Board public meeting in Wallasey Town Hall.  I won’t post in detail on this meeting but will provide a link to John Brace’s blog, as I’m pretty sure he’ll make a very good job of that, along with providing a link to his own video of the occasion.

The five public servants in attendance at the meeting were:

Graham “Mistakes” Burgess (CEO)
Joyce Redfearn (Chair)
Councillor Phil Davies (Council Leader)
Mike Thomas (External Auditor of Grant Thornton, ex-Audit Commission quango servant)
Dr Gill Taylor (Local Government Association – local authorities ‘national voice’)

The whole thing was described by the people out front as “relaxed and informal”, however sadly, this didn’t extend to the voicing of questions.   Most of the public gallery found themselves very much gagged, unless they’d lodged a question previously.  I found it pretty difficult to sit there and contain myself given the stream of denial, subterfuge, duplicity, minimisation, sheer evasiveness and general concealing gloss that poured forth by the bucket load, mainly via the now made permanent (but way before his ‘review point’) CEO Graham Burgess.

Anyway, I’ll now leave it to others.  So apart from mentioning the fact that Councillor Phil Davies, who looked uncomfortable throughout, departed the meeting before courageous whistleblower Martin Morton gave his address, this is where my take on these depressing events must end.

The main reason I’m posting is to describe the very brief  conversation I had with the Head of Law, who I bumped into in the lobby on the way out.  His name is Surjit Tour and he’s been the council’s monitoring officer ever since Bill Norman departed for pastures new at Herefordshire Council (loaded down with £151,000 of our cash).  I rang Wirral Council the other day, enquiring after the person responsible for branding 3 of my Freedom of Information requests “vexatious”.  I was told, “Surjit’s in a meeting.”

So from that point on, the penny dropped that it was not Rosemary Lyon (the name stated on the replies to date) who’d actually been dealing with it.  The “vexatious” brainwave seems to have originated from her boss – the top man.  Had he ordered her to put her name to it rather than signing it himself?  I don’t know.

Anyway, I walked up and introduced myself, then described how two of my FoI requests had been branded “vexatious”, and then how I’d managed to persuade the Information Commissioner to overturn them and find in my favour, thereby ensuring the council released the information or found another reason to state why they couldn’t.

I then asked him to consider, in this climate of austerity and council cuts, withdrawing the final “vexatious” rebuttal – in order to spare his very expensive time and to save a good wodge of our precious council tax payers’ money (which we all know to our cost has been frequently squandered hand over fist on doomed at the outset legal crusades).

His response was typical of the default, machinating, spinning, denying, concealing, minimising, defensive beast of a council that we’ve all grown to know and deeply distrust, and which operates entirely in a bubble of its own creation.  I’m paraphrasing slightly:

“We receive an enormous number of Freedom of Information requests here at Wirral.  How am I to know what you are referring to?”

Evasive and disingenuous doesn’t really come near to describing this.  Because when you’re a practising, professional, senior law person, and you’re brought down twice in succession by an unqualified ‘nobody’ – who’s lost both of his council jobs and whose main claim to fame is overturning two sets of bogus “gross misconduct” charges, then you’re going to damn well remember the name of your vanquisher.  It will be seared into your memory the same way the image of a 100 watt light bulb gets burned onto your retina if you stare at it for a while.

In fact, I’ll be surprised if some senior public servants haven’t got effigies of me that they stick pins in, when they’re not otherwise occupied sticking the boot in on disabled people, complainants and whistleblowers.

Yes, it was me.  Remember the name, because when I introduced myself yesterday, that won’t be the last time you all hear it.  In fact I predict one day you’ll be sick to the back teeth of hearing that name, particularly if you all decide to pursue your senior careers here at “refreshed and renewed” *nods to AKA* Wirral Council.  I live in Seacombe, so I’m never very far away.

Finally, here’s a link to the “Improvement” Board’s draft report.

To ease the flow of the strangulated jargon within, the following key words, which were seen to pepper both the Martin Smith and Anna Klonowski reports, have been carefully omitted from this one:

  • ABUSE (admitted to by the then council leader (see 7.1 here)
  • BULLYING (CEO James Wilkie called to Martin Morton’s house to apologise for this in person)
  • MOBBING (Alleged by Martin Morton and never denied by the council)

I haven’t read the “Improvement” Board draft report yet, nor have I done a forensic search for whatever other scandalous conduct may have been surgically cut out, but on the early evidence, the ‘unscrutinised machinations’ seem to have ascended to a whole new level, whereby senior officer behaviour that threatens legal consequences (see page 5 of Martin Smith Report – The Legal Position) is to be HUSHED UP and not addressed, all with the assistance of Joyce Redfearn’s “Improvement” Board.  I’ll get round to reading it hopefully soon.

And whilst on the subject of the Martin Smith report into abuse of power and bullying – warning – this is damned ugly to gaze upon, and those with finer sensibilities may wish to avert their eyes, but on yesterday’s evidence, Graham “Mistakes” Burgess and Phil (shameless, unapologetic, inveterate liar (see hereherehereherehere, and here)) Davies appear to be content to leave this untouched, in its present, hideously got at form… They’re justifying withholding it by quoting the trusted favourite, ‘personal data’

06 02 13 - excerpt from Smith report

However… even a cursory glance through it reveals that they’ve obliterated a LOT more than just names.

Bye for now…

About Wirral In It Together

Campaigner for open government. Wants senior public servants to be honest and courageous. It IS possible!
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to I meet my “vexatious” accuser face to face !

  1. mdryan.uk@gmail.com says:

    Well, oh well Paul, its all coming together now; and there’s no hiding place for them.

    Well done to you for your persistence. I know it seems hard but as far as I am concerned, the jigsaw is coming together. I reckon power is in the hands of the collective, the people of Wirral. The difficult bit is whether people care (or are bothered enough) to do anything constructive and positive to challenge those in authority.

    My favourite (of the moment) saying remains ……………..

    “Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely!”

    I’ve been out of circulation and keeping a fairly low profile publicly ………….. but as Arnold Schwarzenegger popularly says in one or two of his early films …………. “I’ll be back”! I’ve quite a lot of work to get through at the moment and need to concentrate on my priorities, as we all need to do from time to time.

    I am trying to put local government affairs on the Wirral near the top of my list but not quite top obviously!

    Rumour has it from a councillor I talk to that CEO Graham Burgess may be playing a blinder (so to speak). Reckoning is that he could be lining himself up to “disappear from our shores” and move on to new pastures (retirement?) but only once the media spinners have convinced the public that the “oil tanker” (culture at the council) has made a turnaround and everything is back on an even keel. Well, facts say that the culture at Wirral Council hasn’t really changed at all and to coin a phrase: [excuse me] …… “they couldn’t manage a pi** up in a brewery”! We all pay for the consequences, sadly, here on Wirral where we live. It should be better, much better. Ask Martin Morton, ask yourself!

    Well done to John Brace (I know him well) and well done to you. Keep going. Eventually the penny will drop with more and more members of the community. Democracy should work but alas its rather rusty here on Wirral and WD40 I’m afraid won’t solve the problem! What will? That’s the big conundrum.

    Keep me posted, would you, if you happen to hear (or determine) anything new or out of the ordinary affecting those at Wallasey Town Hall, Brighton Street, CH44 8ED. I’ll do the same for you.

    Just to reiterate one last point: I find you blog really great to read – thanks.

    All the very best and take care



  2. joeddj says:

    oh my how you are hurting them…..love it, excellent writing…….


  3. John Brace says:

    Usually I don’t update my blog at the weekend, but I’ve broken my general rule for the second time this weekend with a blog post entitled The Klonowski Files (Part 1) Equality and Human Rights Commission letter dated 29th December 2010 thanks to your supply of the letter which covers some of the Improvement Board meeting and well as some comments and observations of my own.

    The other lady you didn’t catch the name of from the LGA was Dr Gill Taylor. She’s the one who wrote the six-page letter two years ago to Cllr Steve Foulkes which incorrectly stated that Martin Morton had been dismissed (which Martin Morton referred to in his speech at the end). That letter can also be found on my blog as it formed part of the business at a Corporate Governance Committee meeting (the predecessor to the Improvement Board).

    The video of the Improvement Board has already uploaded in full. Thanks to some compression software I’m managing to do it a lot quicker than I used to. It’s in five parts, Wirral Council Local Government Association Improvement Board 15th November 2013 Part 1, Wirral Council Local Government Association Improvement Board 15th November 2013 Part 2, Wirral Council Local Government Association Improvement Board 15th November 2013 Part 3, Wirral Council Local Government Association Improvement Board 15th November 2013 Part 4 and Wirral Council Local Government Association Improvement Board 15th November 2013 Part 5. There is also a playlist of all five parts so you can watch from start to finish if you wish.


  4. Pingback: ???!!! – 2040 information law blog

  5. mdryanuk says:

    The following forwarded message makes for quite interesting reading and underlines just how rotten (in my humble opinion) local government politics is here on the Wirral. I note Power Boy Pip has come a bit unstuck though and its interesting to try and speculate how disappointed he must be feeling. Shame we can’t change things at Wallasey Town Hall because PR men don’t do very much except earn themselves a tidy crust; kidding themselves that all of the public are really very impressed with all the spin. Politics is a dirty game when it comes down to it; sadly accountability went out the window a very long time ago. Decisions are almost always taken behind closed doors! Take care. Its a very wet evening outside here in Heswall. Lucky I suppose to have a roof over our heads! I wonder whether its our politicians invented that way of thinkng. Brings into my mind the quote used on many occasions: “power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely”! Oh, happy days / or should I say happier days! Another quote for you all ……….. “the pen is mightier than the sword”! Over & out. M 10/08/16 @ 20:29 hours BST


Leave a Reply to John Brace Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.