#Brickgate – Angela Eagle and The Guardian – a further update, and probably not the last

1st August 2016

Archie Bland has written an article in The Guardian, dated yesterday, 31st July 2016:

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/31/how-did-the-language-of-politics-get-so-toxic

For the purposes of this post, I’d ask readers to scroll to the end, where you’ll see a reference to an earlier statement which had been removed:

archie blands excised statement

We’re very pleased to see that the penny is finally beginning to drop with The Guardian, or at least with one of its journalists.

Although the damaging implications of such an error are not explored, mentioned or even hinted at by Archie, we hope that this (limited) acceptance and willingness to clarify is followed up and built upon by his colleagues Anushka Asthana and Hadley Freeman.

They’ve both written articles, one of which repeated this falsehood.  The other, a sympathetic interview with Angela Eagle, failed to enquire of Angela why she’d allowed what she and Anushka must have known to be inaccurate assertions to stand uncorrected, to be built upon and to multiply, virus-like, across the UK’s printed, visual and audio media.

We’ve discussed the issues with Anushka on Twitter and both authors still have an opportunity to follow Archie Bland’s lead and make corrections, perhaps with an explanation as to why it was necessary and why it was delayed.

Readers may be pondering, ‘why is this important’?

It’s because there was an almighty failure by at least a dozen newspapers who, on 12th July, ran with a story that was fundamentally inaccurate, with a central assertion that:

  • Angela Eagle’s office window had been smashed by a brick
  • Angela Eagle’s office / surgery had been attacked by somebody

All the relevant stories are here:

Further irresponsible statements from interviews, taken in reaction to the incident, implied or claimed that Corbyn supporters were involved – with no evidence to support such implications or claims.

Many of the reports failed to make it clear that Angela was not present at the time, in fact nobody was present at the time – because it happened overnight, some time on 11th or 12th July.

Some wider context would be advisable.  At the very least, 6.89 million printed newspaper readers (that’s excluding online viewers) will have absorbed the main falsehood, got angry – who knows?  Then found their anger being inflamed by Angela Eagle’s accompanying statements, calling for Jeremy Corbyn to “call off” the people who were behind this – with absolutely no evidence that the throwing of the brick was connected to the Corbyn leadership campaign.

I am a constituent of Anglea’s and her cynical, reckless conduct here and loose grasp of the facts was to me simply hideous, unforgivable and was the same kind of scraping of the barrel so often indulged in by the woeful gutter press that Angela often queues up to publicly criticise.

This is rank hypocrisy in all its glory.  But if history is to be believed, it’s something to be expected of politicians – a point not addressed incidentally by  Archie Bland – who in his own article above, largely fell into the trap of ascribing Jo Cox MP’s brand of goodness to the same old hard-bitten villains – whom we won’t mention by name but who don’t  deserve it. You’ll know who they are by reading the article.

An initial IPSOS complaint has been lodged with The Daily Telegraph.  This action was not possible with The Guardian as they do not subscribe, but it will be followed by further complaints re: other newspapers.

Whilst the limited action taken on behalf of Archie Bland is welcome, it does not amount to full acknowledgment.  Time is of the essence and there’s a very important leadership ballot ending on 21st September, followed by a crucial announcement at Labour’s autumn conference.

In order for the results of this election to be fairly arrived at and not to have been unfairly influenced, full, global retractions and apologies are required by all those responsible.

In my opinion, full reparations are due, utilising the same column space as the originals, accompanied by printed and online apologies.

The initial actions were reckless and irresponsible, yet foreseeable and avoidable.  The newspapers’ ongoing failure to act accordingly upon written, verbal and online complaints has only succeeded in entrenching their now untenable positions.

About Wirral In It Together

Campaigner for open government. Wants senior public servants to be honest and courageous. It IS possible!
This entry was posted in Angela Eagle and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to #Brickgate – Angela Eagle and The Guardian – a further update, and probably not the last

  1. Pingback: #Brickgate – Angela Eagle MP – Freedom of Information Request to Merseyside Police | Wirral In It Together

  2. David Lynch says:

    The web article was published at 18.00 on the Sunday. The correction was also dated Sunday so was published in less that 6 hours, something of a record for speed of a correction. However the print edition still included the line and the Guardian has not published the correction in its correction column as I thought their standards required them to do.
    I have counted 11 articles on their website that make the allegation about the brick through the office window. Sometime around the 15th July they switched from “through the office window” to “at Angela Eagle’s office” or some such form of words, with the occasional article still slipping through and they still kept raising the incident. It does amaze me that they can keep finding new ways to bring the matter up. I’m beginning to wonder why I believe anything the Guardian prints.

  3. Pingback: #Brickgate / Angela Eagle / Broken Stairwell Window – Our Complaint to the Independent Press Standards Organisation | Wirral In It Together

  4. Pingback: #Brickgate / Angela Eagle Broken Stairwell Window is now with the Information Commissioner’s Office | Wirral In It Together

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s