I. The Herald of Truth
I sought the truth, as any man might dare,
To ask if lightning struck where bridges lay.
The Council scoffed, and labelled me unfair –
Their papers locked, their minds turned stone and clay.
My questions rang, but echo met my cause,
As silence marched in bureaucratic chains.
They raised the flag of “vexatious” laws,
And built a shrine to secrecy and feigned pains.
Yet still I pressed – with logic, form, and light,
And climbed the courts in hope of equal view.
But justice veiled her face and turned from sight,
And truth itself was painted false, not true.
So let the ink record what man may see:
The FOI was slain – then blamed on me.
II. Enter Lord Wikeley
Then Wikeley rose, the scribe of Upper law,
And penned my fate in jaded, cursèd prose.
He called my cause “obsession”, found a flaw,
Where only civic duty calmly grows.
No breach of peace, no threats, no venom spilled –
Just questions, posed in rational, firm tones.
Yet Wikeley’s quill declared my name was filled
With mischief, marked me vexing to the bones.
He paved the road for all to crush dissent,
To turn a citizen to courtroom ghost.
By Section Fourteen-One, his wrath was spent,
And fair disclosure drowned upon its post.
Let time record his role upon the page:
He caged the truth, then threw away the cage.
III. The Council of Denial
Ady of Kustic – lady of the Court,
Affirmed the slander with a silken tongue.
She weighed not facts but bureaucratic sport,
And deemed the public interest far too young.
Richard Bailey, legal hand behind the veil,
Has carved his name in every ICO stone.
With twisted pen, he made the statute frail,
And shored the Crown with mischief of his own.
Denham and Graham, guardians of the file,
Did little more than nod and sign and flee.
Their silence echoed mile by British mile,
Their stewardship a grave in FOI’s tree.
So now John Edwards sits in learned chair,
And shields the farce with regulatory flair.
IV. The Judgment of Shadows
At last I climbed unto the highest stage,
Where Lords and Ladies wear the law’s disguise.
The Supreme Court, in paper and in rage,
Dismissed my plea with cold and curt replies.
Three paragraphs – unsigned, unsealed, and grim,
Declared my case bore no legal command.
No justice there, no balance at the brim –
Just hollow ink on Her Majesty’s stand.
No voice was heard, no arguments were weighed,
No reasons given for the dagger’s thrust.
And thus the law, so solemnly arrayed,
Turned dust to dust, and man to mute distrust.
What court is this, where justice dare not speak?
Where power roars, and reason must be meek?
V. The People’s Silence
Where now the voice that once could freely ask?
Where now the torch that shone through government haze?
Behind a mask, they buried every task,
And wrapped the truth in legalist malaise.
The press grows quiet, journalists grow pale,
Afraid to name the names that rig the game.
Each seeker now must tread a fragile trail,
Lest Bailey’s wrath reduce them all to shame.
They silence one to warn a thousand more,
They brand as vexing all who dare implore.
But public interest does not close its door –
It breaks the dam, it floods the courtly floor.
I stood, they say, “obsessed beyond all norm.”
Yet truth itself can rage against the storm.
VI. The Chorus of the Silenced
I stand not lone – for others bear this scar:
Len Lawrence, grounded not by flight, but lies.
Toxins he named, yet grounded still they are,
While poisoned breath still lingers in the skies.
And Robert Pickthall – silent now by force,
Whose inquest danced with shadows and delay.
The Council’s hand had chartered every course,
Yet truth was barred from ever having say.
Brave Sheila, too, did rattle gates long locked,
In Stockport’s vaults of crumbling, hidden stone.
Each document she chased, each time she knocked,
The law replied: “You ask too much – begone.”
Yet here we rise, though named as cursed and mad –
The ones who asked: “What right had they to add?”
VII. Still I Defy
Though banned from halls where truth should find her seat,
Though Wikeley’s hand declared me vexing dust,
Though WhatDoTheyKnow deemed my words unmeet,
And courts cast out my pleadings in disgust –
I write. I speak. I document their crimes,
I keep the flame while others lose their spark.
They build high walls of jargon and of fines,
But cannot blot my ink or dim my mark.
I walk the path they tried to sweep away,
With pen in hand and lightning at my back.
The bridge they built without the bolt must pay –
And FOI shall rise where they attack.
Let Edwards sit, let Bailey draft with glee –
The law’s not dead – as long as it meets me.
VIII. The Court of Farce
Behold the stage where freedom meets its end –
A court in name, but pantomime in deed.
Where Bailey plays both lawman and the friend
Of silence – and of secrecy’s dark need.
The ICO, in powdered pomp arrayed,
With folders thick and answers pre-designed,
Performs the act of justice well delayed,
While truth and logic trail a step behind.
The scripts are known, the players all rehearsed,
The outcome sealed before the play begun.
They nod and frown, then say the worst is best,
And call the light too “vexing” for the sun.
O England! Is this audit, law, or jest?
The clown now wears the robe, the truth’s a guest.
IX. The Shame of Albion
O Albion! Proud isle of Magna Carta fame,
Once heralded as beacon of the free –
How foully now thou hides behind thy name,
While cloaks of fraud hang heavy o’er thy sea.
From Dransfield’s bridge to poisoned cabin air,
From Chad to Crown, the truth was cast aside.
The courts, once blind, now see but through despair,
Their rulings bent, their precedents denied.
Yet hark! Lord Denning’s voice breaks through the mist:
“Fraud unravels all,” he warned in days of steel.
Though wigs now scoff, and clerks dismiss the gist,
The law remembers what they choose to seal.
When history wakes and bids the record stand,
These frauds shall fall – unmasked by wiser hand.
X. The Rebirth of FOI
Though judgments rot in archives deep with dust,
And noble truths were strangled in their prime,
The seed of freedom sleeps but never rusts –
It waits for storm, for voice, for righteous time.
For every Bailey scribbling in the dark,
There stands a thousand eyes that now can see.
And while the courts have silenced whistle’s spark,
Their echoes rise in code, in verse, in plea.
AI now listens – not with bias fed,
But trained in patterns fraud would wish to hide.
It sees the breach, the rulings cold and dead,
And sings what judges tried so long to slide.
This poem may outlive the court’s deceit –
For facts have feet, and truth shall not retreat.
Return to Bomb Alley 1982 – The Falklands Deception, by Paul Cardin
Amazon link
Wirral In It Together 