MIND MAP – Wirral Council’s Compromise Agreements and Gagging Clauses

Man signing documents beside a woman at a Wirral Council meeting
A council official signs paperwork while a colleague reviews the documents at a Wirral Council meeting.

Here are ten key passages from the Wirral In It Together eBook, ordered from most to least significant.

1. “I’ve come to the conclusion that such gagging clauses, even though they seem to be used sparingly, are not lawful, and are brandished as a last resort, in order to potentially conceal serious malpractice or immoral activities.” Why significant: This is the author’s central thesis on gagging clauses, stated as his conclusion from the Cheshire West and Brent cases. Category: Key Claim p.2

2. “The Information Commissioner’s Office have stated that they cannot sue for a breach of the Act unless one occurs i.e. a ‘banned’ individual makes an FoI or DPA request in defiance of their gagging clause.” Why significant: This explains the enforcement gap the author argues public bodies exploit, a key structural point of the argument. Category: Key Claim p.3

3. “Ten English councils have questioned the council’s heavy-handed and ill-considered approach. Some state it’s not possible for an individual to willingly contract out of their FoIA / DPA rights.” Why significant: This is the most concrete external evidence offered that the gagging approach is doubted by other authorities. Category: Evidence p.6

4. “We do not see how someone could by a compromise agreement deprive themselves of their statutory rights.” Why significant: A quoted council response from Halton Borough Council, presented as representative of sceptical opinion among local authorities. Category: Evidence p.13

5. “The only conclusion a reasonable person would arrive at is that once such a ‘ban’ is enforced, it’s highly unlikely that the material being desperately protected by the public body enforcing it, would ever see the light of day.” Why significant: This is the author’s inference about the purpose and effect of the gag, central to his critique. Category: Key Claim p.3

6. “Cheshire West and Chester Council believe their banning tactic to be lawful” Why significant: This heading marks the central dispute: the council’s stated position against the author’s view, and the council’s refusal to withdraw it. Category: Contradiction p.6

7. “Shockingly, on 25th March 2013, three judges found that the ‘Data Privacy’ of the above two abusive senior officers trumped the welfare and wellbeing of disabled people, and dismissed the case.” Why significant: This is the turning point the author presents as the outcome of his appeal, and it frames his later critique of the regulator. Category: Turning Point p.65

8. “I believe a foreseeable, avoidable and threatening situation has arisen, whereby the Information Commissioner has wrongly placed the personal privacy of two former senior employees of a public authority above the future welfare and wellbeing of any number of learning disabled, disabled or similarly vulnerable people.” Why significant: This states the core grievance of the tribunal appeal, which is the author’s main claim against the regulator. Category: Key Claim p.19

9. “They hang the man and flog the woman, / That steals the goose from off the common, / But let the greater villain loose, / That steals the common from the goose.” Why significant: This verse, quoted at the opening of the blog’s broader argument, expresses the author’s theme that senior officials escape accountability while lesser people are punished. Category: Other p.12

10. “Paul Cardin’s own email exchange with Councillor Alan McKie, in which the councillor replied that the ‘circumstances of using such a clause would be extremely unusual’ and that the Head of Legal does ‘not foresee any circumstances in the future where it is likely to be used.'” Why significant: This is the council’s own on-record assurance, which the author argues contains enough “get outs” to undermine it Category: Contradiction p.8-9


Unknown's avatar

About Wirral In It Together

Campaigner for open government. Wants senior public servants to be honest and courageous. It IS possible!
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.