To: annainsworth@wirral.gov.uk (annainsworth@wirral.gov.uk), colinbaldwin@wirral.gov.uk (colinbaldwin@wirral.gov.uk), paulabasnett@wirral.gov.uk (paulabasnett@wirral.gov.uk), garybennett@wirral.gov.uk (garybennett@wirral.gov.uk), stephenbennett@wirral.gov.uk (stephenbennett@wirral.gov.uk), angeladavies@wirral.gov.uk (angeladavies@wirral.gov.uk), georgedavies@wirral.gov.uk (georgedavies@wirral.gov.uk), stevefoulkes@wirral.gov.uk (stevefoulkes@wirral.gov.uk), elizabethgrey@wirral.gov.uk (elizabethgrey@wirral.gov.uk), brendahall@wirral.gov.uk (brendahall@wirral.gov.uk), pauljobson@wirral.gov.uk (pauljobson@wirral.gov.uk), tonyjones@wirral.gov.uk (tonyjones@wirral.gov.uk), briankenny@wirral.gov.uk (briankenny@wirral.gov.uk), daisykenny@wirral.gov.uk (daisykenny@wirral.gov.uk), louiseluxonkewley@wirral.gov.uk (louiseluxonkewley@wirral.gov.uk), paulmartin1@wirral.gov.uk (paulmartin1@wirral.gov.uk), grahamemcmanus@wirral.gov.uk (grahamemcmanus@wirral.gov.uk), juliemcmanus@wirral.gov.uk (juliemcmanus@wirral.gov.uk), tonymurphy@wirral.gov.uk (tonymurphy@wirral.gov.uk), richiepitt@wirral.gov.uk (richiepitt@wirral.gov.uk), suepowellwilde@wirral.gov.uk (suepowellwilde@wirral.gov.uk), jeanrobinson@wirral.gov.uk (jeanrobinson@wirral.gov.uk), markskillicorn@wirral.gov.uk (markskillicorn@wirral.gov.uk), kaitlinstuart@wirral.gov.uk (kaitlinstuart@wirral.gov.uk), paulstuart@wirral.gov.uk (paulstuart@wirral.gov.uk), mikesullivan@wirral.gov.uk (mikesullivan@wirral.gov.uk), jerrywilliams@wirral.gov.uk (jerrywilliams@wirral.gov.uk), janwilliamson@wirral.gov.uk (janwilliamson@wirral.gov.uk), maxbooth@wirral.gov.uk (maxbooth@wirral.gov.uk), helencameron@wirral.gov.uk (helencameron@wirral.gov.uk), tonycox@wirral.gov.uk (tonycox@wirral.gov.uk), grahamdavies3@wirral.gov.uk (grahamdavies3@wirral.gov.uk), andrewgardner@wirral.gov.uk (andrewgardner@wirral.gov.uk), jeffgreen@wirral.gov.uk (jeffgreen@wirral.gov.uk), andrewhodson@wirral.gov.uk (andrewhodson@wirral.gov.uk), kathyhodson@wirral.gov.uk (kathyhodson@wirral.gov.uk), jennyjohnson2@wirral.gov.uk (jennyjohnson2@wirral.gov.uk), maryjordan@wirral.gov.uk (maryjordan@wirral.gov.uk), ianlewis@wirral.gov.uk (ianlewis@wirral.gov.uk), simonmountney@wirral.gov.uk (simonmountney@wirral.gov.uk), cherrypovall@wirral.gov.uk (cherrypovall@wirral.gov.uk), lesleyrennie@wirral.gov.uk (lesleyrennie@wirral.gov.uk), vidawilson@wirral.gov.uk (vidawilson@wirral.gov.uk), jobird@wirral.gov.uk (jobird@wirral.gov.uk), patcleary@wirral.gov.uk (patcleary@wirral.gov.uk), chriscooke@wirral.gov.uk (chriscooke@wirral.gov.uk), harrygorman@wirral.gov.uk (harrygorman@wirral.gov.uk), naomigraham@wirral.gov.uk (naomigraham@wirral.gov.uk), judithgrier@wirral.gov.uk (judithgrier@wirral.gov.uk), gailjenkinson@wirral.gov.uk (gailjenkinson@wirral.gov.uk), edlamb@wirral.gov.uk (edlamb@wirral.gov.uk),
(craigmcdonald@wirral.gov.uk), ruthmolyneux@wirral.gov.uk (ruthmolyneux@wirral.gov.uk), kieranmurphy@wirral.gov.uk (kieranmurphy@wirral.gov.uk), ewantomeny@wirral.gov.uk (ewantomeny@wirral.gov.uk), jasonwalsh@wirral.gov.uk (jasonwalsh@wirral.gov.uk), allanbrame@wirral.gov.uk (allanbrame@wirral.gov.uk), christophercarubia@wirral.gov.uk (christophercarubia@wirral.gov.uk), philgilchrist@wirral.gov.uk (philgilchrist@wirral.gov.uk), stuartkelly@wirral.gov.uk (stuartkelly@wirral.gov.uk), helenraymond@wirral.gov.uk (helenraymond@wirral.gov.uk), mikeredfern@wirral.gov.uk (mikeredfern@wirral.gov.uk), tomlaing@wirral.gov.uk (tomlaing@wirral.gov.uk), jameslaing@wirral.gov.uk (jameslaing@wirral.gov.uk), gillianwood@wirral.gov.uk (gillianwood@wirral.gov.uk), amandaonwuemene@wirral.gov.uk (amandaonwuemene@wirral.gov.uk), margaret.greenwood.mp@parliament.uk (margaret.greenwood.mp@parliament.uk), alison.mcgovern.mp@parliament.uk (alison.mcgovern.mp@parliament.uk), mick.whitley.mp@parliament.uk (mick.whitley.mp@parliament.uk), eaglea@parliament.uk (eaglea@parliament.uk);
Excerpt:
“One wonders how many masts have been installed in Wirral over this 9 year period using this fake certification system, in what could amount to an organised system of fraud being perpetrated upon the people of Wirral, leaving them unprotected against over exposure to radiation. We are not yet sure how many there are, but it possibly amounts up to 100 !
This is fraud. An independent investigation into how this happened is now essential.
Fraud unravels everything.”
Subject: Copy of public letter to Paul Satoor CEO Wirral Council sent 29 April 2024;
URGENT Information for all Wirral Councillors and MPs.
Slightly adjusted hard copies of this letter have also been sent to The Planning Inspectorate, The Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, Merseyside Police, The Serious Fraud Office and the National Crime Agency.
The evidence for the claims is attached to the email.
Lord Denning said in Lazarus Estates Ltd v Beasley:
“No court in this land will allow a person to keep an advantage which he has obtained by fraud. No judgment of a court, no order of a minister, can be allowed to stand if it has been obtained by fraud. Fraud unravels everything. The court is careful not to find fraud unless it is distinctly pleaded and proved; but once it is proved, it vitiates judgments, contracts and all transactions whatsoever…”
J Cook et al
(details provided) Wirral Council
PO Box 290
Brighton Street
Wallasey
CH27 9FQ
29 April 2024
Dear Paul Satoor,
URGENT CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
…………………………………………………………………………………………
The Fraud Act 2006 provides one general offence of fraud which can be committed in three different ways:
(i) By false representation
(ii) By failing to disclose information
(iii) By abuse of position
The Act also created the key new offence of obtaining services dishonestly.
…………………………………………………………………………………………
We write to you in your position as the Chief Executive Officer of Wirral Council, on behalf of a large and growing group of residents in the Wirral, to inform you of a situation in our borough that you may or may not be aware of, and that demands your urgent and immediate attention.
As CEO of Wirral Council, and associated company names, you hold overall responsibility, and therefore liability, for the decisions that you, and employees working under you, sign off on.
We wish to formally complain in the strongest possible terms regarding the conduct of Wirral Council Planning Department with regards to the granting of Prior Approval for the applications to install 5G telecommunications apparatus at 6 different locations in Wirral.
We believe that we have uncovered fraudulent commercial activity operating, or being facilitated, within both the planning application process at Wirral Council, and the appeals process at the Planning Inspectorate. It is unknown at this point where the fraud originated. Further investigations will reveal that information.
Those responsible may be bad and / or ignorant actors from the private and / or public sectors, but it remains the staunch and statutory duty of the public sector employees charged with the various levels of oversight to exercise the necessary diligence to recognise, investigate and prosecute this criminality. They have failed to do so thus far.
Now that you have been presented with this evidence, we need to remind you of your duty to diligently investigate this unlawful and illegal behaviour, without fear or favour, at both local and national levels of government as well as within sectors of the telecommunications industry.
When it is established that our claims of ‘fraudulent misrepresentation’ and ‘obtaining services by way of deception,’ amongst other charges, are correct, then as our fiduciary representatives, you are obliged to begin proceedings to immediately quash the relevant permissions, de-commission and remove the monopoles and associated cabinets and restore the lands to their original conditions.
Failure to do so could lead to public sector employees, including yourself, being charged with some of the following charges: ‘Abuse of power in public office’ ‘Misappropriation of public funds’ ‘Gross negligence’ ‘Grave dereliction of duty’ ‘Misconduct in public office’ ‘Malfeasance in public office’ and ‘Misfeasance in public office.’
There is also the possibility of a Criminal investigation being initiated should no remedy be provided, as Merseyside Police, the National Crime Agency, the National Fraud Squad, the Serious Fraud Office and the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities are also being contacted.
This letter complies with Civil Procedure Rules for Pre Action Protocol and constitutes a Letter Before Claim.
We presently have over 150 telecommunications masts in the Wirral. We are unsure as to exactly how many are 5G ready, be it newly installed, or upgraded, but believe it to be about 35.
We made ourselves aware of all 5G planning applications in Wirral throughout 2023.
To summarise our findings:
Between 12 December 2022 and 31 December 2023, there were 43 applications for new 5G installations in Wirral, including 2 upgrades. 2 applications were then subsequently withdrawn.
Of those 41 remainingapplications, Wirral Council had the good sense to dismiss 35, whilst granting Prior Approval for 6 (5 installations and 1 upgrade.)
1 telecom company appealed to the Planning Inspectorate in an attempt to overturn 6 of those 35 dismissed applications.
The Planning Inspectorate, an executive agency, sponsored by the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities,dismissed 5 of those 6 appeals, and allowed 1.
Therefore, this has resulted in permission being granted or allowed for a total of 7 installations (6 masts and 1 upgrade) to be deployed in the Wirral area in 2023.
Of those 7 approvals, 2 masts have already been installed, 4 are awaiting installation, and we are unsure if the 1 upgrade has been completed or not.
We would like to draw your attention to 4 important issues regarding our findings.
1.
Of the initial 43 applications submitted between 12December 2022and 31 December2023, 1 was from Arqiva Limited, 1 was from Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Limited, 2 were from Three UK, 6 were from Cignal Infrastructure UK Limited and 33 were from CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited.
Of the 10 applications from Arqiva, Cornerstone, Three and Cignal, 1 was withdrawn, 2 were granted by Wirral Council, with the remaining 7 applications being dismissed. There were some faults and inconsistencies in the planning decision making processes, but all 10 applications were submitted legitimately.
Of the remaining 33 applications from CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited, 1 was withdrawn, 4 were granted by Wirral Council, with the remaining 28 applications being dismissed.
Of those 28 dismissals by Wirral Council, 6 were appealed by CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited and 1 was subsequently allowed by the Planning Inspectorate.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………….
‘CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited’ ceased to trade on 16 November 2022, and began trading as ‘Cignal Infrastructure UK Limited,’ as evidenced by the enclosed document issued by Companies House.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………….
Therefore, CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited did not exist when all of those applications were submitted, appealed or decided.
This means that all 33 of the CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited applications, including the 4 decisions granted by Wirral Council and the 1 successful appeal allowed by the Planning Inspectorate were potentially fraudulent applications and decisions.
This also means that NOcompany will hold responsibility for these 5 masts.
The 4 potentially fraudulent granted decisions by Wirral Council were numbered:
ANTX/22/02163 – Hoylake Road
ANTX/22/02167 – Dock Road
ANTX/23/00006 – Barnston Road
ANTX/23/00008 – Borough Way.
The 1 potentially fraudulent decision allowed by the Planning Inspectorate was numbered:
ANTX/23/00211 – 3326909 – Arrowe Park Road.
Of these 5 applications, only ANTX/22/02163 is sited. The remaining 4 are, as yet, un-sited, although work has begun on the ANTX/23/00211 – 3326909 site on 22 April 2024.
This is fraud. An independent investigation into how this happened is now essential.
Fraud unravels everything.
2.
All of the 33 applications from CK Hutchison Networks (UK) Limited were supported by a certified Declaration of Conformity to ICNIRP guidelines (as required by the National Planning Policy Framework) issued by a company named ‘Three UK Limited.’
4 of the remaining 10 applications for 5G masts from Cignal Infrastructure UK Limited, Three UK, Arqiva Limited and Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Limited, were supported by a certified Declaration of Conformity to ICNIRP guidelines issued by a company named Three UK Limited.
That is a total of 37 applications made to Wirral Council, 6 of which were also subject to appeal to the Planning Inspectorate, that were supported by a certified Declaration of Conformity to ICNIRP guidelines issued by a company named Three UK Limited.
This means that only 6 of the initial 43 applications were supported by a certified Declaration of Conformity to ICNIRP guidelines that was issued by a company other than Three UK Limited.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………….
‘Three UK Limited’ was dissolved on 27 October 2015, as evidenced by the enclosed document issued by Companies House.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………….
Therefore, Three UK Limited did not exist when all of those applications were submitted, appealed or decided.
This means that 37 of the 43 applications made to Wirral Council, including the 4 decisions granted by Wirral Council and 1 appeal allowed by the Planning Inspectorate, were supported by a potentially fraudulent certified Declaration of Conformity to ICNIRP guidelines, a forged and false instrument, issued by a company named Three UK Limited, that has not existed since 2015.
Of the 7 successful applications (6 Council and 1 Inspectorate) only 2 had legitimate certification, meaning 5 had certification from Three UK Limited that was not legitimate.
When we talk about legitimate certification, we mean that the company that certifies the declaration actually exists. 3 companies – Cignal Infrastructure UK Limited, Arqiva Limited and Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Limited all existed at the time of the application, and still exist, according to Companies House, and all certified their own equipment. Most people would assume that an independent body of expertise would need to certify the equipment, but that is not for us to say. If this is what is deemed legitimate at this point, then so be it.
For a legitimate company to use the name of a non existent company to certify something is bad enough, so for a non existent company to use the name of another non existent company, by way of a false instrument, to certify something that guarantees public safety is categorically illegal, unlawful, even lawless.
This is made worse when we understand that the forged, false instrument relates to the involuntary exposure of the general public to radiation (an environmental toxin.)
This means that there were NO assurances of public safety contained within these 5 approved mast decisions.
It just so happens that these 5 decisions (4 by Wirral Council and 1 by the Planning Inspectorate) are also the same 5 decisions that involve a successful application from a non existent company, as in issue number 1.
The 4 potentially fraudulent granted decisions by Wirral Council were numbered:
ANTX/22/02163 – Hoylake Road
ANTX/22/02167 – Dock Road
ANTX/23/00006 – Barnston Road
ANTX/23/00008 – Borough Way.
The 1 potentially fraudulent decision allowed by the Planning Inspectorate was numbered:
ANTX/23/00211 – 3326909 – Arrowe Park Road.
Of these 5 applications, only ANTX/22/02163 is presently sited. The remaining 4 are, as yet, un-sited, although work has begun on the ANTX/23/00211 – 3326909 site on 22 April 2024.
We are compiling the data to document how many successful applications there are going back to 28 October 2015 involving the same potentially fraudulent behaviour in the ICNIRP certification
process.
One wonders how many masts have been installed in Wirral over this 9 year period using this fake certification system, in what could amount to an organised system of fraud being perpetrated upon the people of Wirral, leaving them unprotected against over exposure to radiation. We are not yet sure how many there are, but it possibly amounts up to 100 !
This is fraud. An independent investigation into how this happened is now essential.
Fraud unravels everything.
3.
This particular issue number 3 does not relate
UPDATE ~ 20th May 2024
Criminal complaint letter received by Wirral CEO:
eturn to Bomb Alley 1982 – The Falklands Deception, by Paul Cardin
Amazon link
Wirral In It Together 
Pingback: Fraudulent 5G masts. 15th May 2024. Urgent criminal complaint to Wirral Council CEO is copied to all 66 Wirral councillors | Wirral In It Together | Wirral In It Together